A Meditation upon the Sufficiency of Existence
Of all the creatures that inhabit the earth, man alone, so far as I can discover, possesses the remarkable faculty of finding his own existence insufficient.
I do not mean that other animals are strangers to hunger, fear, desire, or discomfort. Nature has distributed these burdens generously among her children. But man appears to have added to them another, of his own invention: the perpetual conviction that his life ought to be taking place elsewhere, at another hour, or under circumstances more agreeable than those which presently attend him.
We are scarcely awake before we begin wishing for the evening. We labour through the week in expectation of its conclusion, and having obtained our leisure, frequently discover that we do not know what to do with it. We regret the years that have departed and hasten toward those that remain, though the latter, once arrived, seldom satisfy us more than the former.
Thus we are forever preparing to live, and forever surprised to discover how much of life has passed during our preparations.
I have been no stranger to this infirmity.
Indeed, I suspect that my own mind has devoted more industry to the correction of yesterday and the improvement of tomorrow than to the enjoyment of any present hour. I have revisited old injuries until they became familiar companions, and constructed future triumphs with such diligence that I sometimes wonder whether their actual occurrence would not disappoint me.
Yet I once experienced, for the space of a single summer night, a condition so different from my ordinary manner of existence that I have never ceased to consider it.
I cannot claim to have understood it. Still less can I claim to have mastered it.
I have never succeeded in recovering it.
But I remember it.
And since a man may sometimes learn more from examining a single unusual occurrence in his own life than from collecting the opinions of a hundred philosophers, I shall endeavour to describe it as faithfully as memory permits.
I. Of a Sofa, and Other Neglected Pleasures
It was summer in Budapest, and a violent storm had been forecast.
My dwelling possessed a large balcony overlooking the Danube, furnished with a sofa, chairs, and various conveniences by which I had attempted to extend the comforts of domestic life into the open air. The balcony was spacious, some forty-two square metres, and separated from the river by a road along which the ordinary business of the city continued.
The meteorologists warned of winds of uncommon violence.
I therefore occupied myself with securing the furniture, fastening whatever might be carried away, and placing the cushions beneath the sofa, where I supposed them least likely to become the property of my neighbours.
Having completed these precautions, I found myself with nothing further to do.
The afternoon was warm. The clouds were gathering, but the storm had not yet arrived. The river moved beneath the darkening sky, and the city continued its accustomed occupations.
Some time earlier, a friend had entrusted me with a small quantity of LSD, advising me, should curiosity overcome prudence, to begin with no more than a quarter of what he had given me.
I followed his counsel concerning the quantity.
As to the wisdom of the undertaking itself, I shall leave that question open.
For some time nothing occurred.
I sat upon my sofa, watched the clouds assemble above the river, and presently forgot almost entirely that I had taken anything.
Then I became aware of the extraordinary comfort of my seat.
I fear that the reader, having been promised an unusual experience, may find this beginning unworthy of his attention. He may have expected strange visions, revelations, or some violent disturbance of the senses. Yet I cannot improve the dignity of the event without departing from its truth.
The first wonder that presented itself to me was a sofa.
I had owned it for some time. I had selected it because it was comfortable, and had subsequently employed it for precisely that purpose. Yet until that afternoon I had never properly considered what comfort meant.
The cushions received the weight of my body with a softness that seemed almost intelligent. The support beneath my back, the distribution of pressure along my legs, the agreeable absence of any necessity to move; all these ordinary circumstances became objects of the most lively interest.
I shifted my position slightly.
The sensations changed.
I shifted again.
Another arrangement of pleasures presented itself.
It seemed absurd that so much agreeable feeling should have been available to me for so long without my having taken the trouble to notice it.
I began to suspect that we are not so much deprived of pleasure as inattentive to its presence.
We pursue extraordinary enjoyments with great determination, travelling considerable distances and expending no small portion of our fortunes in their acquisition, while neglecting those humble satisfactions which accompany us daily and ask nothing in return.
I do not pretend that the comfort of a sofa can replace the pleasures of love, friendship, achievement, or adventure. But I wondered whether the value we assign to our sensations depends less upon their actual character than upon the attention we are willing to bestow upon them.
I looked at my hands.
The fine hairs upon their backs were moving in the breeze.
I had seen these hairs before, naturally, but had never considered them individually. Now each appeared distinct, bending beneath currents of air so slight that I could scarcely feel them upon my skin.
Some moved while others remained still.
A faint movement passed across my hand, and the little hairs answered it in succession.
I watched them with the fascination ordinarily reserved for some rare spectacle.
How many times, I wondered, had this occurred without securing a moment of my attention?
How much of the world passes before us in this fashion, not hidden, but disregarded?
I could not determine whether my senses had acquired some new power or whether an accustomed negligence had simply deserted me.
Perhaps the distinction was of less importance than I supposed.
For whatever the cause, I was receiving the testimony of the world with an intensity entirely unfamiliar to me.
And I found that testimony sufficient.
My thoughts, however, had not yet become entirely philosophical.
For if the modest pleasure of sitting upon a sofa could be magnified to such a degree, I naturally wondered what might become of pleasures already celebrated for their intensity.
I thought of making love.
This consideration seemed worthy of investigation, and I telephoned my companion.
I described my condition with enthusiasm and suggested that she join me.
Unfortunately, my explanation was less precise than my intentions. She understood me to be inviting her to partake of the substance herself, a proposal which inspired considerably more apprehension than desire.
She declined.
I might ordinarily have been disappointed. I might have regretted the misunderstanding, rehearsed a more persuasive explanation, or entertained some resentment that my invitation had been refused.
Instead, I accepted her decision without the least disturbance.
The conversation ended.
And with it ended my concern.
This absence of disappointment seemed remarkable.
For I then discovered that a great multitude of other concerns had likewise disappeared.
I was no longer occupied with the past.
Nor was I preparing for the future.
The little tribunal in which I ordinarily prosecute myself for former errors had adjourned its proceedings. The theatre in which I rehearse my future triumphs had fallen silent.
I was seated upon a sofa.
The air moved over my hands.
And I desired nothing beyond what was already present.
II. Of the Beasts, and the Burdens of Reason
It occurred to me that perhaps the beasts, whom we so readily consider our inferiors, possess certain advantages which our reason has not entirely compensated us for losing.
I thought particularly of cats.
A cat may remain motionless for a considerable time, apparently engaged in no occupation whatsoever. Yet the slightest disturbance will command its attention. An insect moving upon a wall, a faint sound from another room, the shifting of a shadow; each becomes worthy of examination.
The animal seems to inhabit a world perpetually offering itself to its senses.
I do not know whether cats are content.
I have observed them displaying impatience, fear, affection, and a determination to obtain food that would do credit to the most ambitious of men. They remember, anticipate, and learn. To suppose them entirely free of the difficulties of existence would be to attribute to them a wisdom for which I possess no evidence.
Nevertheless, I wondered whether a cat, lying comfortably in the afternoon sun, torments itself with the memory of some foolish action committed years earlier.
Does it imagine a future in which it shall become a more accomplished cat?
Does it despise the present hour because it has not yet obtained the honours it believes itself destined to receive?
I suspected not, though I could offer no proof.
And I began to consider whether the same faculty which permits man to extend his understanding beyond the present may also condemn him to a peculiar exile from it.
We possess memory, and therefore regret.
We possess imagination, and therefore dissatisfaction.
We possess the ability to conceive what is absent, and consequently find ourselves surrounded by absences even when the world before us is abundant.
I do not condemn these faculties. Without them we should possess neither history nor prudence, neither art nor civilization.
But I wondered whether we have allowed them to occupy so much of our existence that the present has become merely a narrow passage between two imaginary countries.
For the first time I could remember, I was not travelling between them.
I had arrived somewhere.
And that somewhere was simply where I stood.
A flash of lightning appeared beyond the river.
A little later, thunder answered.
The storm was approaching.
III. Of the Storm
I have known the rains of Sweden, where the heavens frequently descend upon the earth with a cold and melancholy persistence that persuades even the most devoted admirer of nature to seek the company of a fireplace.
But a Hungarian summer storm is another creature altogether.
It gathers beneath a warm sky. The air remains heavy with the heat of the day, even as enormous clouds assemble overhead. Darkness advances across the city, yet the last sunlight may still illuminate the distant edges of the storm, lending them a grandeur which no painter could easily reproduce.
Such was the spectacle that now presented itself above the Danube.
The first drops fell upon the balcony.
They struck the wooden floor separately, each announcing its arrival with a small and distinct sound.
Then others followed.
The intervals diminished, the sounds multiplied, and presently the rain descended with such abundance that the individual drops could no longer be distinguished by ordinary attention.
The city beyond the balcony became veiled in water.
Lightning illuminated the clouds.
Thunder rolled across the river and between the buildings.
I rose to inspect the furniture, but found everything secure. The winds of which we had been warned had not arrived with the rain, and there seemed no immediate necessity to retreat indoors.
The wooden floor still retained the warmth of the afternoon.
The air, though gradually cooling, remained agreeable.
I removed my shirt.
Occasionally the rain reached beneath the shelter and touched my chest. The water was neither warm nor cold enough to trouble me. It was simply water, arriving upon my skin and departing again.
I began to attend to these sensations with the same interest that I had earlier bestowed upon the hairs of my hands.
The movement of air across my shoulders.
The occasional touch of rain upon my chest.
The changing pressure beneath my feet.
The sounds of water striking wood, stone, leaves, and the distant surface of the river.
Each sensation possessed its own character.
Each seemed worthy of notice.
I had no desire to distinguish the agreeable from the disagreeable, for almost nothing presented itself as disagreeable.
The world was happening around me, and I was receiving it.
Then I became aware of something which, though less spectacular than the lightning, astonished me far more.
I was not bored.
I had been standing upon my balcony for some time, occupied with nothing that could properly be called an activity. I was not reading, speaking, working, or pursuing any particular object.
Yet I experienced not the slightest impatience.
I did not wonder how long the storm would continue.
I did not wish for some greater spectacle to interrupt it.
I did not think of returning indoors to occupy myself with more profitable affairs.
The present moment required no improvement.
I considered this with growing curiosity.
For what is boredom?
We commonly attribute it to the absence of interesting circumstances. Yet I have known men who were bored in the midst of considerable entertainments, and others who remained perfectly content while engaged in occupations that would have driven their neighbours to despair.
Perhaps boredom belongs less to the world than to our manner of receiving it.
Perhaps it arises when we cease to attend to what exists and begin demanding what does not.
I could not establish this as a universal truth.
But there, upon my balcony, it seemed to describe my condition.
The storm might continue for another hour.
It might end in the next minute.
I was equally content with either prospect.
For the first time in my life, so far as I could remember, I did not require the next moment to justify the present one.
As the storm grew more intense, I found myself increasingly occupied by the abundance of sensations.
The lightning, the rain, the movement of the clouds, the changing light upon the river; all demanded attention, and I seemed capable of giving it without exhaustion.
Yet I began to desire a narrower field of perception.
I closed my eyes.
I placed my feet apart, firmly upon the wooden floor, and raised my arms outward. My chest faced the storm, and my head inclined slightly upward.
I cannot explain why I adopted this posture.
It was not the consequence of any deliberate ceremony. I entertained no thought of invoking the gods, of challenging the heavens, or of presenting myself before some invisible judge.
Had a stranger observed me, he might perhaps have supposed that I was engaged in an act of worship.
But I was not worshipping.
I was not asking for anything.
I stood in that manner because it seemed agreeable to stand so, and I had no reason to alter it.
With my eyes closed, the world changed again.
The storm, which had previously presented itself chiefly as a spectacle, became an immense arrangement of sounds.
Rain struck the wooden floor with one character, the pavement below with another. Water moved among the leaves, descended from roofs, and gathered upon surfaces I could not see.
Thunder travelled above the city, sometimes arriving as a distant murmur, sometimes as a tremendous vibration that seemed to occupy the whole of the air.
Yet within this tumult I discovered an extraordinary capacity to direct my attention.
I could listen to the storm as a whole, receiving its countless sounds as one immense movement.
Or I could attend to something smaller.
The faintest disturbance might emerge from the greater noise and occupy my awareness as completely as the thunder itself.
I seemed to possess, for the time being, a faculty resembling an instrument of remarkable precision.
In the language of my profession, I might compare it to an array of receivers, gathering innumerable signals and distinguishing one from another.
I do not know whether my hearing had truly become more acute.
It may be that my perception of its precision exceeded the actual power of my ears. A mind altered by a substance is not necessarily a reliable judge of its own instruments.
But this qualification does not diminish the experience as I remember it.
I felt capable of attending to the smallest sounds while the greatest continued around me.
And I was perfectly calm.
I did not strain to hear.
I did not fear missing anything.
My attention seemed to move of its own accord, selecting one disturbance and then another, while the storm continued its vast proceedings.
I could have remained thus indefinitely.
Or so it seemed to me.
For I had ceased to measure the value of the hour by the events it contained.
IV. Of a Woman, a Dog, and the Proper Business of Animals
It was while attending to the sounds beneath the storm that I heard a woman’s voice from the street below.
She was speaking upon her telephone.
The violence of the weather had evidently alarmed her, and she was describing her predicament to a friend with considerable urgency.
She wished to return home.
Her difficulty was a dog.
The animal, it appeared, did not share her understanding of the situation.
She urged it to hurry, expressing with increasing impatience the necessity of reaching shelter before the weather became still worse.
But the dog had discovered a matter requiring immediate attention.
It stopped.
And began to piss.
The woman protested.
The dog continued.
I could hear her efforts to persuade the creature that the circumstances were unsuitable for such an undertaking, but the animal seemed entirely unmoved by her arguments.
Here was a small comedy unfolding beneath the greatest spectacle the heavens could provide.
Above us, clouds discharged their waters upon the city, lightning illuminated the darkness, and thunder announced the movement of immense forces.
Below, a woman attempted to negotiate with a dog concerning the proper time and place to empty its bladder.
The contrast delighted me.
I had the impression that I could distinguish even the tiny sounds of the animal relieving itself amid the innumerable drops of rain striking the pavement and grass.
Whether I truly heard so much, or merely believed that I did, I cannot now determine.
But the whole affair presented itself to me with astonishing clarity.
It lasted perhaps thirty seconds.
Then the dog completed its business, the woman hurried away, and their voices disappeared into the storm.
I remained where I stood.
I had no wish to follow them with my thoughts.
Their little drama had begun, occupied its proper interval, and ended.
It required no continuation.
Yet the incident remained sufficiently amusing to provoke a further consideration.
The woman had been desperate to escape the present circumstances.
The dog, meanwhile, had been occupied by a necessity that admitted of no postponement.
I do not pretend that the animal possessed some superior philosophy. It is more likely that its bladder had simply overruled its concern for the weather.
Nevertheless, the contrast seemed instructive.
Man carries within himself an elaborate conception of what ought to be happening.
The animal attends, more immediately, to what is happening.
And although I would not willingly exchange my reason for the understanding of a dog, I could not help wondering whether the latter was sometimes the happier creature.
The rain continued.
The thunder moved above the river.
And I returned my attention to the world without the least sense that anything had been lost.
V. Of the Spider
It was then that I became aware of a curious division within my own consciousness.
I seemed to possess two minds, or rather two occupations of the same mind, proceeding simultaneously without disturbing one another.
The first attended entirely to the world.
It received the sounds, the movements of air, the occasional rain upon my chest, and the innumerable disturbances passing through the night.
It performed this office without effort.
There was no impatience in it, no desire for novelty, no fatigue arising from the continued exercise of attention.
The second mind contemplated the first.
It examined this strange tranquillity, questioned its nature, and sought some comparison by which it might be understood.
Ordinarily, when I become absorbed in thought, the world around me diminishes.
A man who is composing an argument in his mind may walk through a familiar street without noticing the houses. He may eat a meal without attending to its flavour, or sit beneath a beautiful sky while considering some grievance that occurred twenty years earlier.
Thought, in such circumstances, appears to purchase its freedom at the expense of sensation.
But now I experienced no such exchange.
I was thinking with considerable intensity.
And I was attending to the world with equal intensity.
Neither occupation seemed to diminish the other.
I found this division so remarkable that I began searching for an image capable of representing it.
And I thought of a spider.
Not the spider that runs across a floor, pursued by a frightened householder, but the patient creature suspended at the centre of its web.
There it remains, sometimes for hours, surrounded by threads of such delicacy that they appear scarcely substantial enough to exist.
Yet these threads constitute an instrument of extraordinary sensitivity.
A movement at one extremity may announce itself at the centre. An insect struggling among the strands sends its disturbances through the whole arrangement. The faintest touch may convey information concerning an event occurring beyond the creature’s immediate sight.
The spider waits.
Or perhaps I should say that it attends.
For waiting, as men commonly understand it, implies the expectation of something not yet present.
We wait for a visitor, for a letter, for the conclusion of a tedious occupation. Our attention is directed toward the future, and the present becomes merely the interval separating us from what we desire.
But the spider, as I imagined it, was not impatient for the next insect.
It remained upon its web, receiving whatever disturbances the world afforded.
An hour might pass without any event of consequence.
Yet I imagined no boredom in the creature.
Its attention was not justified by the frequency of incidents, but by the continuous possibility of receiving them.
I must confess that this conception may tell us more about myself than about spiders.
I know little of their inward lives. Whether they experience anything resembling contentment, impatience, or boredom is a question upon which I possess no authority.
Perhaps I was merely projecting my own unusual condition upon an animal incapable of confirming or denying the comparison.
But even if the spider of my meditation was partly my own invention, the image remained useful.
For I too had become an attentive creature at the centre of a web.
My web was the balcony.
The threads were the innumerable sounds and sensations by which the surrounding world announced itself.
The storm moved through them.
The woman and her dog had moved through them.
The air, the rain, the thunder, and the distant city continually presented their testimony.
And I received it.
I did not require some great event to occur.
Indeed, I did not require any event at all.
The faintest movement was sufficient.
Even the absence of movement seemed worthy of attention.
I began to understand that the condition I was experiencing was not excitement.
Excitement depends upon something occurring, or upon the expectation that something soon will.
My condition was different.
I was content even when nothing changed.
This distinction occupied me for a considerable time.
For I had always supposed that the value of an hour depended, at least in part, upon what one accomplished or enjoyed within it.
An hour spent in labour might be valuable because of its fruits.
An hour spent in pleasure might be valuable because of the delight it afforded.
An hour spent in study might be valuable because of the knowledge acquired.
But what of an hour in which nothing is accomplished, nothing pursued, and nothing desired?
I had ordinarily regarded such an hour as empty.
Yet here I stood, accomplishing nothing, pursuing nothing, and desiring nothing, while experiencing a fullness of existence unlike anything I could remember.
I had not become indifferent to the world.
Quite the contrary.
I had become so attentive to it that no additional occupation seemed necessary.
And then I considered time.
It had not slowed.
I was perfectly aware of its passage.
The minutes continued in their ordinary succession, and the storm moved through its natural course.
Yet I no longer experienced the passing of time as a loss.
I did not wish to hasten it.
Nor did I wish to preserve the moment against its departure.
The present was not precious because it might soon disappear.
It was precious because it was present.
And when it disappeared, the next moment would be present in its place.
I wondered whether the great difficulty of human existence might lie not in the brevity of our lives, but in our unwillingness to inhabit the portions of them that we possess.
We complain that life is short.
Yet how eagerly we dispose of its hours.
A man who wishes away his working day, his journey, his waiting, and his solitude may discover at the end that he has spent a considerable portion of his allotted existence asking it to pass more quickly.
I recognized myself in this folly.
Indeed, I had practised it with such diligence that I might reasonably have been considered an expert.
Yet now, for reasons beyond my understanding, the habit had deserted me.
I stood upon my balcony, my arms extended, my eyes closed, and the storm moving around me.
Time passed.
And I was content to accompany it.
VI. Of the Majesty of Things
The storm had now attained its greatest violence.
Even through my closed eyelids, the flashes of lightning were visible.
They illuminated the darkness within my eyes, appearing suddenly and vanishing before I could form any deliberate expectation of them.
The thunder followed with such force that I felt its vibrations within my ears.
At times the sound seemed to roll across the entire city, gathering strength as it passed between the buildings and over the river.
At other times it arrived with a sudden violence that appeared to shake the air itself.
The rain descended in torrents.
The heavens seemed occupied by forces so immense that all the ordinary affairs of mankind might have appeared insignificant beside them.
Yet I did not feel insignificant.
Nor did I feel great.
I was not comparing myself with the storm.
I understood its power perfectly well. I knew that the lightning was dangerous, that the forces before me were indifferent to my wishes, and that no confidence of mine could diminish their strength.
But I felt no fear.
Neither did I experience joy.
I did not rejoice in my courage, for I was not attempting to be courageous.
I did not delight in having overcome some trial, for I had undertaken none.
I did not feel anger, triumph, or the exaltation that sometimes accompanies the contemplation of great spectacles.
I was simply present.
The distinction is difficult to communicate.
For we are accustomed to describing extraordinary experiences by the emotions they provoke.
A mountain inspires awe.
A battle inspires terror.
A victory inspires joy.
A loss inspires grief.
But I stood before a spectacle of immense power without feeling compelled to answer it with any corresponding emotion.
I understood what was happening.
I attended to it.
And that was enough.
The storm did not require my admiration.
Nor did I require its acknowledgment.
It existed according to its nature, and I according to mine.
For those hours, the two seemed to require no reconciliation.
I was not outside nature, contemplating it as a spectator seated before a performance.
I was within it.
The air moved around my body.
The rain touched my skin.
The thunder entered my ears.
The wooden floor supported my feet.
The storm and I occupied the same world, and I had no desire to separate myself from it.
I knew, naturally, that I had taken a substance capable of altering perception.
Yet I resisted the thought that the experience was therefore unreal.
The lightning was real.
The rain was real.
The thunder was real.
My body was real.
If my manner of receiving these things had changed, it did not follow that the things themselves had become imaginary.
I do not claim that I had discovered some hidden order of the universe.
I had received no revelation, heard no divine voice, and encountered no truth which I could demonstrate to another man.
I had merely experienced the world with an intensity and tranquillity entirely unfamiliar to me.
But I could not persuade myself that this was a trivial matter.
For if a man who has spent decades finding existence insufficient can suddenly experience it as complete, even for a single night, then there is surely something concerning the nature of his ordinary dissatisfaction that deserves examination.
I did not pursue this argument to its conclusion.
There was no necessity.
The storm continued.
And I remained within it.
VII. Of the Departure of the Storm
No storm remains forever above one city.
Gradually the lightning became less frequent.
The thunder withdrew into the distance, its great disturbances diminishing until they seemed to belong to another part of the world.
The rain continued for a time.
Then it weakened.
The sounds upon the pavement grew less numerous, and the great continuous roar separated once more into smaller disturbances.
Finally the rain stopped with a suddenness that surprised me, almost as though someone had turned off a tap.
I remained standing.
My eyes were still closed.
My arms were still extended.
I had no wish to move.
The absence of the rain seemed, in its own fashion, as remarkable as its presence had been.
The great noise had departed, and beneath it lay another world of sounds which had been there all along.
I attended to them.
The distant city.
The faint movements of the air.
The occasional disturbance that emerged from the quiet and disappeared again.
I was still the spider upon its web.
And the web, though no longer shaken by the storm, remained worthy of attention.
I felt no disappointment at the departure of the thunder.
I did not regret that the lightning had ceased.
The storm had come, occupied its proper interval, and departed.
I had accompanied it.
And now I accompanied the silence.
After some time, birds began to sing.
At first there were only a few calls, faint and separate.
Then others answered.
Their songs gathered among the trees as the first light of morning appeared beyond the distant hills.
The night was ending.
I listened.
The birds possessed no greater claim upon my attention than the rain had possessed, nor any lesser one.
They were simply the sounds that now belonged to the world.
I received them with the same contentment.
And then, without warning, the experience ended.
VIII. The Return
I became aware of my arms.
They were in considerable pain.
My shoulders ached, my muscles protested, and the posture which had seemed so effortless now appeared almost impossible to maintain.
I became aware of the cold.
My body was wet, and the warmth of the previous afternoon had long departed. I began to shiver.
The air, which I had received so willingly upon my skin, had become an enemy against which I desired immediate protection.
My feet hurt.
My back hurt.
I was exhausted.
And with these familiar discomforts returned another sensation, no less familiar and perhaps more disheartening.
I was bored.
There was no gradual philosophical awakening, no final insight by which I might preserve something of the condition I had enjoyed.
One moment I had been entirely content to stand beneath the heavens.
The next I was a cold and miserable man upon a balcony, wondering why he had been foolish enough to remain outside all night.
I lowered my arms.
Slowly, I opened my eyes.
The first light of morning was appearing above the distant hills. The clouds had passed, and birds were singing in the trees.
The world was peaceful.
I was not.
I went inside.
I returned to the sofa upon which the whole affair had begun.
It was the same sofa, possessing neither more nor less of those agreeable qualities which, only the previous afternoon, had appeared to me so worthy of admiration. Yet I now found in it nothing remarkable. Its cushions received my weight, its back supported my shoulders, and I was grateful for these services only insofar as they relieved me of the necessity of standing.
I fetched a heavy blanket and wrapped myself in it, though not without some difficulty, for my arms had become exceedingly painful. I had held them extended for so long that they now seemed determined to exact payment for every minute of their former obedience.
My body shivered, and I drew the blanket closer.
Outside, the birds continued their morning songs.
I had listened to those same birds only moments earlier with an attention so complete that their smallest notes had seemed sufficient to occupy my whole existence. Now I scarcely heard them. My thoughts were already elsewhere.
I began to consider how long it might take for my body to become warm.
Then I thought of the things I ought to accomplish that day, and of others which I had neglected on previous days. Certain old regrets presented themselves, followed by familiar hopes concerning the future. Before long I was once again conducting arguments with absent persons and arranging victories over difficulties which had not yet arisen.
I recognized these occupations as old acquaintances.
Indeed, I had scarcely been seated a quarter of an hour before I found myself wishing that the quarter of an hour had already passed.
This amused me a little, though not sufficiently to make me forget the cold.
For I had just spent an entire night discovering, or believing that I had discovered, how unnecessary such impatience might be. I had stood for hours beneath a violent storm, content with the mere passage of time, and had required neither diversion nor reward. Yet here I was, unable to endure the modest interval necessary for a blanket to restore warmth to my limbs.
It would have been agreeable to suppose that the experience had made me wiser.
I searched myself for evidence of this improvement and found very little.
I understood, or thought I understood, something which had previously escaped me. But understanding a thing and possessing the power to practise it are not the same accomplishment. A man may know perfectly well that anger is foolish and nevertheless become angry; he may discourse most elegantly upon moderation while reaching for another glass of wine. I have known men who could explain every virtue and exercise scarcely one of them, and I should be reluctant to place myself above their company.
So it appeared with contentment.
I had experienced it in a form which I had never imagined possible, yet I could no more summon it than command the departed storm to return above the Danube.
I tried for a moment to recover the manner in which I had attended to the world.
I listened to the birds.
They were still singing, and their songs were no less beautiful than before. But my attention wandered almost immediately toward the discomfort in my shoulders, the cold beneath the blanket, and the question of what I should do when I had recovered sufficient warmth to rise.
I could remember the former state with extraordinary clarity.
I could not inhabit it.
This distinction troubled me more than I cared to admit.
For memory, which so often preserves the image of our pleasures, is a poor instrument for restoring them. It may show us the country in which we once found ourselves happy, but it cannot always carry us back across the border.
I have never since returned to that condition.
Nor do I know whether I ought to regret its disappearance. Perhaps a man who remained perpetually content with whatever lay before him would accomplish very little. Our dissatisfaction, troublesome companion though it is, has built cities, crossed oceans, composed books, and raised children. Much that is admirable in mankind has arisen from the refusal to leave things as they are.
Yet I cannot persuade myself that we have gained everything by this bargain.
For a few hours I had known what it was to possess the present without wishing to exchange it for another moment. I had not become a better man, nor a greater one. I had merely ceased, for reasons I cannot fully explain, to find existence insufficient.
And then I had become myself again.
I sat beneath the blanket, with my arms aching and my teeth occasionally chattering, while the first sunlight appeared above the distant hills.
There was nothing wrong with the morning.
The storm had passed, the birds were singing, and the world was as worthy of attention as it had been an hour earlier.
But I was cold, and I wished to be warm.
I was uncomfortable, and I wished to be comfortable.
And having nothing to occupy me while these wishes remained unanswered, I was bored.
I pulled the blanket closer and waited.
